The real american war in vietnam a book by nick turse. Pierre asselin explains the formative experiences and worldview of the men who devised communist strategies and tactics during the conflict, and analyzes their rationale and impact. Army advisory effort to the south vietnamese armed forces during the period when the u. The base repelled several north vietnamese army nva probes and defeated a major attack in may 1967, leaving 49 marines and 197 nva soldiers dead. The history and the tactics is an excellent book about the conflicts in vietnam from before world war ii to the end of the u. Combat advisors lived and fought with south vietnamese combat units, advising on tactics and weapons and liaising with local u. Guerrilla warfare tactics, in their simplest forms, are used to allow smaller forces to defeat much larger ones. This is a very popular misunderstanding in indonesia.
With the end of the cold war in 1992 soviet military equipment subsidies ended and vietnam began the use of hard currency and barter to buy weapons and. The genius of north vietnams war strategy the daily beast. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. According to vietnamese custom, this person should properly be referred to by the given name giap. The editor has excellent photos from the time when the french battled the vietminh to when the u. He first grew to prominence during world war ii, where he served as the military leader of the viet minh resistance against the japanese occupation. Thus, soldiers in the south vietnamese army were organized into large divisions and trained to fight in conventional wars completely unlike what they were facing against the viet cong. North korean national strategy and military policy foundation kim il sung ruled the democratic peoples republic of korea dprk from its inception in 1948 until his death in. Life and death in the south vietnamese army modern war studies hardcover.
Sep 22, 2018 this is very much a book about soldiers for soldiers. Are we talking about the whole war or the fall of saigon. In his 1984 memoir he reflected on american military tactics in vietnam. His second book, what it is like to go to war, excerpted below, bares his. The development and training of the south vietnamese army, 1950. The most admirable thing about this falls pbs series on the vietnam war is the way in which it forces american audiences to confront the. The vietcong and north vietnamese army used essentially infantry tactics, and mobility was the key to all operations, from the small actions of the local forces to the larger actions of the regular forces. Far from being monolithic, the vietnamese and american armed forces were each comprised of men of differing talents and abilities. They tried to force me to confess that i was a member of the vietcong. Whole war, they were viewed as americas ugly step children. The south vietnamese army had come into the village after american bombing and artillery had driven out the enemy.
They organized a new guerrilla army of south vietnamese communists, which became known as the vietcong. Among critical subjects treated are our command relationships with the south vietnamese army, our politicomilitary efforts to help reform both the south vietnamese military and government, and our implementation of the vietnamization policy inaugurated in 1969. Brigham provides an example of the consequences of ignoring familial values, priorities, concepts of honor and responsibility, family obligations, and political training for an armed force expanding during wartime. It looks at operations in vietnam in the context of the tactics, operational philosophy, training, and equipment of the units sent to fight there. Among the strengths of this book are the authors analyses of arvn. In this passage she explains what happened to her when she was captured by the south vietnamese army. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading north vietnamese army soldier 195875 warrior book. Campaigns of the vietnam war united states army center. The real american war in vietnam is not only one of the most. Hung, nguyen tien and schecter, jerrold, the palace file new york. The name is said to have first been used by south vietnamese pres.
The enemy rarely accepted battle in unfavorable situations and only accepted decisive contact under exceptional circumstances. Life and death in the south vietnamese army modern war. John paul vann, widely considered one of the most effective and committed u. The name is said to have first been used by south vietnamese president ngo dinh diem to belittle the rebels. Because of this, the army in vietnam utilized tactics and. Why the forgotten south vietnamese army is the most. Why the japanese were the evilest and most immoral army of. His vice president lyndon johnson assumed the presidency. Like any army, arvn units were generally as good as their officers and their training. Such initiative was sometimes blunted by arvn countermeasures, or the aggressive search and destroy tactics of us. After four months of intense offensive operations in the. Jun 10, 2019 the battle of khe sanh began on january 21, 1968, when forces from the peoples army of north vietnam pavn carried out a massive artillery bombardment on the. By mid1960 the advisory group numbered nearly 700 u.
From 1945 to 1973, more than 100,000 members of the u. Life and death in the south vietnamese army lawrence. This battle reverberated all the way to washington, dc, leading to the major policy shift of immediately demilitarizing the dmz. Many liberation army of south vietnam units operated at night, and employed terror as a standard tactic. The author discusses a turning point in the war that came in 1968 with the tet offensive, a massive campaign launched by the north vietnamese army and the viet cong against major urban areas and military installations in south vietnamese. During the vietnam war 19651975 and the cambodianvietnamese war 19771989, the vietnam peoples ground forces relied almost entirely on sovietderived weapons and equipment systems.
Army units were involved in the cambodian incursion. The vietnamese communists, or vietcong, were the military branch of the national liberation front nlf, and were commanded by the central office for south. The chief of armor, a general staff officer, theoretically had no tactical authority but. Today, vietnamese leaders expect to continue using asymmetric tactics, though this time, military operations will take place in the air and at sea to contend with china in the south china sea, grossman adds.
This was highly effective due to their mastery of it. The viet cong and the north vietnamese peoples army of vietnam pavn used wellorganized logistics methods to supply and equip their fighting forces. Meanwhile, as president nixon became embroiled in the watergate scandal that led to his resignation in august 1974, north vietnamese forces stepped up their attacks on the south and finally launched an allout offensive in the spring of 1975. He described the tactics of both sides and outlined how the south vietnamese were supported by america forces, while the north vietnamese received supplies from. This was combined with a massive refurbishment of the north vietnamese army, with the assistance of china and the soviet union, that allowed the offensive to kick off at a time when the south. Just as the first anzacs were far more effective soldiers by 1918 than they had been in 1915, so too the south vietnamese army was more effective in the early 1970s than it had been in the early 1960s.
Supported instead of taking over south vietnamese peoples job of defending their country. Mar 27, 2015 the south vietnamese army first took shape after the 1954 geneva agreement when the american military assistance advisory group maag commanded by lieutenant general john odaniel set about creating a modern military force, funded by the us, that was capable of defending south vietnam against an invasion by troops from north vietnam. Lacking the firepower of the american forces, the vietcong used ambushes, booby traps, and other guerrilla tactics. Vo nguyen giap is considered one of the greatest military strategists of the 20th century. Extremely corrupt, lazy they were there for the whole thing. He explains how the advisors essentially trained the south vietnamese military according to the u. The vietnam war was a military conflict fought between north vietnam, supported by their communistic allies, and south vietnam, supported by the united states and other anticommunist allies. To counter the american buildup, vietcong recruitment would be stepped up and more north vietnamese army troops would be infiltrated into south vietnam. Armed forces of the vietnam war pritzker military museum. North vietnamese army soldier 195875 warrior book 5 kindle edition by rottman, gordon l.
The story of an loc is based on an incident depicted in robin moores book, the green berets, an. North korean national strategy and military policy foundation kim il sung ruled the democratic peoples republic of korea dprk from its inception in 1948 until his death in 1994. The south vietnamese army, with a strength of about 150,000, was equipped with standard army equipment and given the mission of delaying the advance of any invasion force until the arrival of american reinforcements. North vietnamese army soldier 195875 warrior book 5. Life and death in the south vietnamese army to scholar and policy maker alike. Life and death in the south vietnamese army by robert k. The army of the republic of vietnam never became a fully legitimate arm of the government because of misguided policies, poor leadership, and a failure to create a vietnamese army with origins in and connections to vietnamese culture and history. President diem and his brother were murdered in a military coup while president kennedy was assassinated in dallas 20 days later.
Nlf and pavn battle tactics comprised a flexible mix of guerrilla and conventional warfare. Anniversary of the battle of hue during the vietnam war. Jun 22, 2009 brigham provides an example of the consequences of ignoring familial values, priorities, concepts of honor and responsibility, family obligations, and political training for an armed force expanding during wartime. This logistics organization helped greatly in their war against the american and south vietnamese military during the vietnam. The south vietnamese army first took shape after the 1954 geneva agreement when the american military assistance advisory group maag commanded by lieutenant general john odaniel set about creating a modern military force, funded by the us, that was capable of defending south vietnam against an invasion by troops from north vietnam. Bob worthingtons first tour 19661967 began with training at the army special warfare school in unconventional warfare, vietnamese culture and customs, advisor responsibilities and vietnamese. Why the forgotten south vietnamese army is the most underappreciated in history.
A us general reflects on military tactics in vietnam 1984. The evolution of us army tactical doctrine, 19461976. Just reread in full for the first time in probably eight years. This book reveals the evolving us, viet cong and nva tactics at battalion level and below throughout the vietnam war. American officers advising the south vietnamese army repeatedly warned washington that the war was misguided. Guerrilla tactics in december 1965, ho chi minh and the north vietnamese leadership ordered a change in a way the war in the south was to be fought. The rise of an insurgency in south vietnam posed significant issues for both the south vietnamese government and for the united states. The strategic hamlet program t his chapter will describe a program designed to help beat ho chi minhs vietcong the communist guerrilla organization attempting to overthrow the diem government. I served in south vietnam as an us army adviser in 196364, with maag, iii corps area. Five myths about the vietnam war the washington post. Viet cong vc, in full viet nam cong san, english vietnamese communists, the guerrilla force that, with the support of the north vietnamese army, fought against south vietnam late 1950s1975 and the united states early 1960s1973. Journalists could not travel around north vietnam and report freely, let alone accompany the north vietnamese army into battle and witness their ruthless tactics.
The program was called the strategic hamlet program. For most americans, there is a lot of mystery that surrounds our old adversaries in the vietnam war. For general lam quang thi, the twentieth century had only twentyfive years. Army, navy, air force, and marine corps personnel, all of whom advised their counterparts in the roughly 150,000man republic of vietnam armed forces. Is it true that vietnam learned about guerrilla warfare. Before 1968 the south vietnamese army also had severe shortages in crewserved weapons, tactical communications, equipment, and light transport vehicles, items that were critical to an army. Vietcong forces defeated south vietnamese army arvn in battle of ap bac. Viet cong, the guerrilla force that, with the support of the north vietnamese army, fought against south vietnam late 1950s1975 and the united states early 1960s1973. List of equipment of the vietnam peoples ground forces. Eleven were awarded the medal of honor, 378 were killed and 93 were wounded. Army in vietnam historical resources the wwi era u. Vietnams plan to counter china is a peoples war at sea. The viet cong were famous for using the guerrilla warfare tactic in vietnam to attack american forces. Originally they were exclusively viet cong in makeup but eventually became predominantly north vietnamese army nva as viet cong casualties mounted, the war escalated, and more and more nva troops were sent south.
Vietnam have long history with guerilla style warfare, first happen in war against ancient chinese dynasty of han in 200s bc. Indeed, one interlocutor told us that vietnam was preparing for peoples war at sea. For victor hugo, the nineteenth century could be remembered by only its first two years, which established peace in europe and frances supremacy on the continent. Readers weighed in on the best books about the vietnam war. Us army war college quarterly the book is a heavily researched, very detailed look at the 1972 north vietnamese army invasion of south vietnam, better known as the easter offensive, which was designed to topple the south vietnamese government and end the war.
Army forces gradually decreased while still carrying out searchanddestroy missions and assisting south vietnamese forces. North vietnamese army soldier by gordon l rottman is part of ospreys warrior series, which seeks to provide insights into the daily lives of historys fighting men and women, detailing their motivation, training, tactics, and experiences. To oversee armor training and the development of armor tactics for the south vietnamese army, the vietnamese armor command, which also served as the office of the chief of armor, was established on 1 april 1955. Houghton mifflin, 1987 is written by a former south vietnamese ambassador to the united states. Army advisers in south vietnam in the early 60s, did not mince words with harkins about the inadequacies. Vietnams american war by pierre asselin cambridge core. Making use of traps, tunnel systems, and a variety of insurgent tactics, the viet cong were a powerful enemy for much of the war. The army and vietnam differs in a unique way in that it looks at how the war was fought from the perspective of army doctrine. Jun 23, 20 vietcong forces defeated south vietnamese army arvn in battle of ap bac. Casualties for the republic of south vietnam will never be adequately resolved. It is estimated to have suffered 1,394,000 casualties killed and wounded during the vietnam war. During the vietnam war 19651975 and the cambodianvietnamese war 19771989. But despite thousands of books, articles and films about this moment in our.
They viewed the americans as tourists they willing to let the ame. The northern viet minh government quickly came to realize that supporting the southern viet cong insurgency would be vital to its own success. This is very much a book about soldiers for soldiers. Marshall chair of military history at the command and general staff college traces the course of the vietnam war from the early advising mission through the largescale combat phase to the vietnamization and eventual collapse of the south vietnamese forces and the fall of saigon. Armed forces of the vietnam war while national leaders decided the direction the war would take, the soldiers on the ground enacted their policy. They also fought the mongols with similar strategy. Combat advisers in vietnam knew the score and got ignored. The viet cong were the south vietnamese communists, and considered a political movement for the people. The residual influence of the army s earlier french training, however, lingered in both leadership and tactics. The south vietnamese experience in the war remains poorly documented. Viet cong, the guerrilla force that, with the support of the north vietnamese army, fought against south vietnam late 1950s1975 and the. Start by marking the army and vietnam as want to read.
This book serves as a great case study in how not to build an army. The 3 pioneer survival lessons we should all learn. Beginning with a description of the terrain, climate and the unique nature of operations in this theatre of war, the author, a vietnam veteran himself, goes on to explain how unit organisation was broken down by combatant forces and the impact this had on the kind of tactics. Cambridge core southeast asian history vietnams american war by pierre asselin. The base repelled several north vietnamese army nva probes and defeated a major attack in may 1967, leaving. Westmoreland plans to destroy the viet congs infrastructure and turn over to a completely retrained south vietnamese army a major portion of the defense of the demilitarized zone and other areas.
Colonel kim, yong bum, north korean tactics instructor, republic of korea army college. Bob worthingtons first tour 19661967 began with training at the army special. In the middle of the night on january 31, 1968, 10,000 north vietnamese and vietcong troops swept into the historic city of hue, a major cultural center in south vietnam. Now that im more familiar with the documentary record concerning vietnam and not just the vietnam literature or the coinasmilitary reform oeuvre, which in many cases are the same thing, krepinevichs tendentious book holds up very poorly indeed.
191 810 1482 1329 485 334 1007 666 880 1232 617 48 9 1169 928 115 193 1100 1540 589 492 705 1056 1065 1055 362 673 738 121 1235 1094 1054 940 1379 1403 797 1333 282 393 1047 8 1292 1170